Florida Roofing Scams: 12 Red Flags Every Homeowner Must Know
Protect yourself from storm chasers, AOB traps, and "free roof" schemes
After every hurricane or storm, they appear: strangers knocking on doors, promising "free inspections" and "no-cost roof replacements." Some are legitimate contractors. Many are not. Here's how to protect yourself.
Why Florida Is the Roofing Scam Capital
Florida's combination of hurricane exposure, complex insurance regulations, AOB loopholes, and insurance market chaos creates perfect conditions for fraud. The state consistently leads the nation in roofing-related insurance disputes and contractor complaints.
The 12 Red Flags
1. They Knocked on Your Door After a Storm
Legitimate companies don't chase storms. If someone shows up uninvited after a hurricane, they're counting on your fear. Reputable contractors earn business through referrals and established reputations — not cold calls on damaged homes.
2. They Offer a "Free Roof" Through Insurance
They inflate claims, submit false damage reports, and you end up with a flagged claim history and higher premiums. There is no such thing as a free roof — someone is paying, and the hidden costs often come back to you.
3. They Want You to Sign an AOB
Never sign an Assignment of Benefits without fully understanding it. Once signed, you lose control of your insurance claim. The contractor can negotiate directly with your insurer, inflate costs, and even sue your insurance company in your name.
4. They Pressure You to Decide Immediately
"This price is only good today" is a manipulation tactic. Real contractors understand that a roof is a major investment and give you time to compare quotes, check references, and make an informed decision.
5. They Demand Large Deposits Upfront
A standard deposit is 10-30% of the project cost. More than that — especially 50% or more — is a major red flag. Scammers collect large deposits and disappear before completing the work.
6. They Don't Have a Physical Address
Storm chasers operate from hotel rooms and rental trucks. No permanent local address means no accountability. If something goes wrong six months later, they're long gone.
7. They Can't Provide License and Insurance
Verify at myfloridalicense.com. A legitimate contractor will provide their license number without hesitation. No license means no legal protection for you.
8. They Won't Provide a Written Contract
No contract means no protection. A proper contract includes scope of work, materials, timeline, payment schedule, warranty terms, and permit responsibilities. Verbal agreements are worthless in a dispute.
9. They Offer to "Help" Pay Your Deductible
This is insurance fraud — and you're a party to it. Florida law prohibits contractors from waiving or absorbing your deductible. If they offer, it means they're padding the claim to cover the difference.
10. Their Estimate Is Way Lower Than Others
If one estimate is 30-40% lower than the rest, something is wrong. They may be using substandard materials, skipping permits, using uninsured labor, or planning to hit you with change orders after starting.
11. They Won't Commit to Pulling Permits
Building permits are required for roof work in Florida. Period. Skipping permits means no inspections, no code compliance verification, and potential problems with your insurance and future home sale.
12. They Have No Reviews or Fake Reviews
Check Google, Yelp, and BBB for consistent, specific reviews over time. Be wary of companies with only five-star reviews posted in a short period — these are often purchased. Real companies have a mix of reviews that span months or years.
What to Do If You've Been Scammed
- Document everything — photos, contracts, texts, emails, receipts
- Contact your bank — dispute the charges if you paid by credit card
- File a complaint with Florida DBPR — the licensing authority for contractors
- Report to the BBB — creates a public record
- Consider an attorney — especially for large amounts
- Notify your insurance company — if a claim was filed without your full understanding
What we do:
- ✓ Verify every contractor's Florida license
- ✓ Confirm liability insurance and workers' comp
- ✓ Check reputation and complaint history
- ✓ Connect you with local contractors
What we don't do:
- × Knock on doors after storms
- × Promise "free" roofs
- × Require AOB signatures
- × Pressure same-day decisions
Red Flag Checklist
- ⚑ Did they knock on your door?
- ⚑ Are they offering a "free" roof?
- ⚑ Do they want you to sign an AOB?
- ⚑ Are they pressuring you to decide today?
- ⚑ Do they want more than 30% upfront?
Verification Checklist
- ✓ Verify license at myfloridalicense.com
- ✓ Call their insurance company directly
- ✓ Get at least 3 written quotes
- ✓ Read the contract completely
- ✓ Confirm they will pull permits
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I check if a Florida roofer is licensed?
Can I cancel an AOB after signing it?
Is it illegal for roofers to go door-to-door in Florida?
What should I do if a roofer offers to pay my deductible?
How many quotes should I get before choosing a roofer?
Work With Vetted Contractors
Skip the guesswork. Every contractor in the HiPoint network is licensed, insured, and reputation-checked.
Get a Free Estimate from Vetted Contractors →